Gibbsville Cheese Co, Inc. Award-Winning Company

W2663 Cty Road OO
Sheboygan Falls, WI 53085
Phone: 920-564-3242
Fax: 920-564-6129


The Van Tatenhove family purchased Gibbsville Cheese Company in 1933. We continue to be a family-run operation with our third generation now at the helm. Our primary production is Cheddar, Colby and Monterey Jack and a variety of flavored cheeses. We are known for our Special Reserve Super Sharp Cheddar that is tested by our cheesemaker to assure the quality reaches "Special Reserve" standards before the label goes on. Our famous Cheese Curds are made on Tuesdays. Call to confirm time. We cut and package 40-pound, 5-pound, and 1-pound blocks for dealers and cheese houses under our own label. Gibbsville Cheese Company operates a retail store, national mail order business, and distributes cheese from the facility.




Group Cheeses By:  

+ American (Pasteurized Processed)
+ Baby Swiss
+ Blue
+ Brick
+ Cheddar Award-Winning Cheese
+ Cheese Curds
+ Colby
+ Colby-Monterey Jack
+ Cold Pack
+ Cream Cheese
+ Edam
+ Farmer's
+ Feta
+ Gouda
+ Limburger
+ Monterey Jack
+ Mozzarella
+ Muenster
+ Parmesan
+ Provolone
+ Romano
+ String
+ Swiss


Forms: 1 lb. Blocks, 1/4 lb. Stick
Varieties: Salted


  • Conversion/Cut & Wrap for OTHER companies
  • Custom Manufacturing/Packaging Capabilities
  • Halal
  • Kosher
  • Organic
  • Private Label

Company Contact Information

Phillip Van Tatenhove
W2663 County Road OO
Sheboygan Falls, WI
Phone: 920-564-3242
Fax: 920-564-6129
Contact for:
All Inquiries